Winter Injury, Earth Science and Tomatoes!

Hello and welcome to The Greenkeeper!  Today is Wednesday, April 18th and Winter Kill is defined in Merriam-Webster as "to kill a plant (or part of a plant) by exposure to winter conditions."  Now, that is a vague definition, but winter kill is a vague phenomenon as exposure to low temperatures alone are not the sole cause of plant injury or death.  To be clear, I am speaking solely about warm-season grasses and specifically about Bermudagrass.

We have over 100 acres of Bermudagrass growing on our tees, fairways, rough, and practice areas, and there are reports of winter injury and winter kill surfacing throughout North and South Carolina again this spring.  This article by the Carolinas Golf Association (CLICK HERE) was released less than two weeks ago as an alert to golfers and owners to help everyone better understand what conditions they are currently experiencing on their golf courses.  Granted the article focuses more on recent ultra-dwarf Bermudagrass putting green conversions, but Bermudagrass grown at any height of cut can be subject to the whims of Mother Nature.  

No. 1 Fairway

I stated above low temperature alone is not a sole cause and factors such as low light (shade), elevated moisture (too wet), and heavy traffic significantly contribute to Bermudagrass injury during cold winters.  Sometimes just a fraction of an inch more in height of cut, or one or two degrees more of temperature can be a difference maker.

Team cleaning up course following yesterday’s storm while we assess winter injury & survival of all Bermudagrass areas. Will detail in blog post later this week, overall less damage than 2015. #CGCturf pic.twitter.com/zIUe6uflr2

— Matthew Wharton (@CGCGreenkeeper) April 16, 2018

This past Monday we assessed the overall health and condition of our 100 acres and determined about 1 acre, or one percent suffers from significant winter injury requiring replacement.  There are some additional areas although injured with enough healthy plant material present they will heal with a little extra management (fertilizer and water) as soon as Mother Nature agrees to provide appropriate growing conditions (but that's a different topic).  Today I want to talk a little about the areas needing replacement, and how we plan to repair them.  But before we get deep into those details let's take a closer look at the golf course from above to gain a better understanding of the types of winter injury we've encountered and why.

Google Earth Image of Carolina GC

Remember back in elementary school when they taught us in Earth Science the sun always rises in the east and sets in the west, and the sun makes its way across the southern sky on its daily trek across the earth.  In the summer the sun travels at a very high arc, nearly overhead and the days are long and quite warm.  In the winter however, the sun is much lower in the sky and the days are shorter.  Also, because the sun is lower in the sky, that angle creates long shadows formed by objects (trees, buildings, etc.) located on the south side.  

Hole No. 1

Holes No. 11 & 12

When I was growing up in VA my grandparents lived in a ranch house that faced due north.  In the winter months there was either frost or snow lingering in the shadow of the house long after it was gone in other portions of the yard.  In the two photos above you notice the trees located to the south and west (in the case of 11 & 12) of the respective golf holes and thus it's easier to understand why the turf in this area of the property may be subjected to more winter related injury than others.

Hole No. 9

Hole No. 16

Holes 9 and 16 are also not immune as they both possess large trees growing on their southern sides that create cooler micro-climates throughout the dormant season.  Even the practice tee located at the back of the range is at risk, as those same trees that provide comfortable shade in the summer provides too much shade during the coldest of winters.

Back Range Tee

Does this mean we need to cut down all the trees?  No, especially since not all the trees I've highlighted are growing on club property.  But what it does mean is there is a reason the majority of winter turf injury during extreme cold years occurs mostly on the southern border of the property.  In fact, of the entire one acre of turf loss estimated approximately 95 percent of it is located in those areas I highlighted above.

Tale of Two Halves

Interestingly, it is not just a factor of trees and shade either.  Do you also remember in Earth Science that cold air sinks and hot air rises?  Well, the area above the blue line is the portion of highest elevation on the property compared to below.  The highest place on the golf course is the tee box on Hole No. 6 at roughly 765 feet above sea level and most of Hole No. 1, along with No.'s 11, 12, and 13 all sit below 700 feet (now you know why most putts break towards No. 1 green).  Sixty-five feet in elevation may not sound like much but when you are talking about prolonged exposure to extreme winter conditions that may cause plant injury, even a few feet can be the difference in a degree or two.

So now you understand why the injured turf on the golf course is located where it is on property, and you want to know what we are going to do about repairing it.  I have reserved two truck-loads of new sod to be delivered in the next two weeks (one truck each week).  This will remedy the injured turf on the golf course.  We will give a little more patience to the practice range areas before committing to new sod.  The plan next week is to replace all the injured turf on the collars and tees before proceeding to other areas in need.  What doesn't get completed next week will be repaired the week after.  

SIDEBAR - I know some of you read "injured turf on the collars" and your heart sinks as that is an issue we battled quite extensively for several years.  I can tell you the amount of turf damage this year is far less than experienced in 2015 and I'm certain the impact to your golf activities will be as minimal as can be.

One other important piece of the ever mystifying winter injury puzzle is varietal differences.  If you're confused by what I'm referring to, I mean the different types of Bermudagrass present on the golf course can have different tolerances to winter extremes.  Wait, you mean you didn't know there are more than one type of Bermudagrass on the golf course.  Well, let me ask you a question, do you like tomatoes?  If yes, what's your favorite type?

Tomato/Tomatoe

You see, there are many different types of tomatoes and similarly there are many different types of Bermudagrass.  Our 100 plus acres is mostly comprised of Tifway Bermudagrass (A.K.A. 419) but there also areas of Tifgreen (A.K.A. 328), Celebration, and Common growing on the golf course along with genetic off-types mutated from the 419 planted ten years ago (Grandma's Quilt).  You may or may not have noticed certain irregular shaped patches greening up quicker than its neighbors earlier this spring.  Similarly, there is a newer Bermudagrass variety now on the market known as Latitude 36 CLICK HERE.  It was bred to possess a higher cold tolerance threshold than 419 or others and is available from our grass supplier.  We will be incorporating some in these injured areas to see how well it passes the test.  Fingers crossed the Latitude 36 could well be the key to reducing winter injury in our susceptible areas in the future.

That's all for now, time to get back on the course and continue to give our Bermudagrass the TLC it needs to get the course where we all want it.  If you have any questions, comments, or concerns please don't hesitate to email me directly.  I am always happy to help.

See you on the course,

Matthew Wharton, CGCS, MG

Rebooting Spring, To Do List, and Kevin Bacon!

Hello and welcome to The Greenkeeper!  Today is Wednesday, April 11th and Patrick Reed is the winner of the 2018 Masters.  Now some of you may recall Patrick successfully qualified for the 2012 Wells Fargo Championship right here at Carolina Golf Club, but before we discuss the degrees of separation between us and the green jacket winner, let's take a close look at some recently completed and ongoing course work as we continue to prepare for spring.

Speaking of spring, we are 41 days into meteorological and 21 days into astrological spring, yet it hasn't really felt much like spring to me.  You recall last post I shared photos from greens aeration where it snowed, and Monday morning while conversing with my superintendent peer from Charlotte Country Club, John Szklinski it began to sleet!  We were comparing notes (okay, lamenting) about the delayed bermudagrass green up we're both experiencing and Mother Nature was definitely having a good laugh at our expense.  The good news is the immediate forecast calls for a warm up to spring like conditions through this weekend. We may even see one or two days at or near 80 degrees.

Brad Panovich

The downside is there are reports indicating one more last blast of winter (or shall I say cooler than average temperatures) may be returning to our area on the back side of this week's warm up.  The chart below reflects the percent chance temperatures will be a departure from normal (average) over the next two weeks beginning back on April 8th and extending through April 24th.  You can see the warm up we are about to experience on the second row, but notice it is short lived as the blue and green hues associated with a cooling trend return to the southeast in rows three and four.  

WeatherBell Analytics

Something about the Madden-Julian Oscillation heading back into phases two and three.  I know, I lost you at Madden-Julian but you can CLICK HERE to learn a little more about the MJO and its impact on our weather in the continental U.S. if you choose.  In the meantime just know that yours truly is ready for the arrival of spring and my team and I are hoping it unpacks its bags and stays for good real soon.

Despite the cooler than average temperatures there has been a good deal of activity on the golf course. Mowing has begun as we've cut select fairways twice and select tees and approaches once each.  Rough is being mowed for the first time today and tomorrow.  Back on April 2nd all bermudagrass areas (tees, fairways, rough, etc.) were fertilized with our custom blend.

Custom Blend

Polyon

Spreader Truck

This fertilizer is formulated based on soil tests and polymer coated to provide a slow, steady feed to our playing surfaces this spring and summer.  As the bermudagrass continues to wake, albeit slowly from its longer than usual hibernation period, this product will provide the plant with the nutrition necessary to develop into the strong turf and premium playing surface we desire for you and your guests.  

Other course related news saw over 30 tree stumps ground and removed back on April 2nd.  A small maple tree growing in the natural/native area left of No. 13 tee was relocated to the natural/native area near No. 14 tee and several lower limbs and branches were pruned from three trees growing left of No. 13 fairway in order to provide an unobstructed view of the bunkers guarding the left side of the fairway.

Phil Flowers Stump Grinding

Maplewood Company

New Home!

Arborguard

Much Improved

Needless to say it's been a little busy of late, and even crowded with all the specialized equipment on property.  And speaking of crowded, the City of Charlotte (Charlotte Storm Water) recently initiated a project on Donald Ross Road that required us to grant them temporary access to a small portion of the property.  Underneath Donald Ross Road is a culvert that discharges storm water into the stream channel below the teeing area of No. 13 and flows across No. 11.  The culvert and concrete headwall were both in a state of decline but CSW has been making quick work of the repairs and should be off site pretty soon.

Charlotte Storm Water on Site

New Boulders In Splash Pool

Repairs to Bottom of Culvert Pipe

So back to our 2018 Masters Champion, Patrick Reed.  You may or may not recall we hosted the qualifying tournament for the Wells Fargo Championship for five consecutive years (2010-2014).  During that time many veteran and aspiring professionals played the course in hopes of securing one of the four coveted spots in the Wells Fargo Championship at Quail Hollow Club.  In 2012 a young Patrick Reed, with then girlfriend (now wife) Justine on the bag as caddie, fired a 5-under par round of 65 (the qualifying tournaments always played No. 13 from a forward tee making it a par 4 and the course par 70) securing a spot in PGA Tour field.  I recall he birdied 18 ensuring he was in the tournament and avoiding the crowded playoff that ensued when ten guys tied at 4-under played off for the final two spots.  That playoff took six holes and two days before everything was determined.  Sidenote: that year Patrick successfully qualified 6 times on the PGA Tour.

Anyway, as I watched the drama unfold this past Sunday evening I remembered our connection, albeit small to this year's Masters Champion.  I searched the results of that year's qualifying tournament and realized that 2014 Fed Ex Cup Champion Billy Horschel was also in that field and in that 10 for 2 playoff (unsuccessful).  I searched the results from the other years and was surprised to remember some of who had played at Carolina Golf Club and what they had gone on to achieve, like Gastonia's Harold Varner III (2016 Australian PGA Champion) finished T25 in 2013, current U.S. Open Champion Brooks Koepka no carded in 2014, and this week's defending champion at the RBC Heritage, Wesley Bryan finished 97th in 2014.  

Anyway, for those of you curious here's a look back at five years of Monday Qualifying at Carolina Golf Club. 

2010  2011  2012  2013  2014 

That's all for now, time to take advantage of these next few warm days and whip this golf course into shape.  With the Masters in the rear view, I know everyone is excited and raring to go.  I'll be back with another update next week with greater detail on some changes to our mowing patterns and hopefully a better idea of the overall state of our bermudagrass health and winter recovery.  Until then...

See you on the course,

Matthew Wharton, CGCS, MG